...Dams in Canada
Parallels between the Malaysian
and Canadian experiences with dams

As the foregoing discussion suggests, there are numerous parallels between past Canadian experiences, and the ongoing experience with the Bakun Dam. Some brief examples include:

  • The environmental impacts of the projects, and of related economic developments; and the implications of these impacts for the wellbeing of affected communities.
  • Concerns about resettlement, and resulting economic and social disruption.
  • The conflict between maintenance of the traditional economic activities of native communities, and integration into the cash economy. In particular, there are useful parallels to be explored between Sarawak and the Canadian north.
  • The significance of dams as symbols of national pride and aspirations.
  • The significance of activism and resistance to development, by those affected by the project.
  • The interaction between federal and state environmental authorities. [The circumstances behind the transfer of authority over the Bakun Dam from the federal to the Sarawak state government, and the role of the courts in determining the validity of this transfer, may be usefully compared with recent Canadian federal and provincial jurisdictional conflicts over dam projects, including the Oldman Dam in Alberta, the Rafferty-Alameda Dam in Saskatchewan, and the James Bay project in Quebec.
  • Efforts to manipulate the environmental impact assessment process. For example, for the Great Whale Project, the Quebec government advocated breaking the EIA process into two parts: to assess the roads and other infrastructure first, and then the dams, thereby enabling construction on the infrastructure to begin sooner. This parallels the strategy followed the Bakun Dam proponents, of breaking the EIA into four parts, in order to accelerate construction.

Sources:
o
Alcan Aluminum, "Setting the record straight on Kemano completion," Compass, 1994, 38(1).
o Berkes, Fikret, "Some Environmental and Social Impacts of the James Bay, Hydroelectric Project, Canada," J. Environmental Management, 1981, 12: 157-172.
o Bourassa, Robert, Power from the North, (Scarborough, Ont.: Prentice-Hall Canada, 1985).
o Canada. Department of Fisheries & Oceans, Government of Canada Outline of Evidence for the British Columbia Utilities Commission Inquiry into the Kemano Completion Project, Phase 3, (March 1994).
o Christensen, Bev, Too Good To Be True: Alcan's Kemano Completion Project, (Vancouver: Talonbooks, 1995).
o Day, J. C., Frank Quinn, "The Kemano Diversion," pp. 85-106, in Day & Quinn eds., Water Diversion and Export: Learning from Canadian Experience, University of Waterloo Dept. Geography Publ. Ser. 36, 1992.
o Dorcey, Anthony H. J., "The Management of Super, Natural British Columbia," BC Studies, 1987, no. 73: 14-42.
o Fearnside, Philip M., "The Canadian Feasibility Study of the Three Gorges Dam Proposed for China's Yangzi River: A Grave Embarrassment to the Impact Assessment Profession," Impact Assessment, 1994, 12: 21-57.
o "Flooding Job's Garden" [videorecording]. National Film Board, 1991. 59 minutes. One of a five part series on native self-government, "As Long as the Rivers Flow". Order number: C 9191 044. [Portrays the impact of the James Bay project on the Cree of Northern Quebec. Boyce Richardson juxtaposes conditions in the region in the early 1970s, before Hydro Quebec began construction, and in 1990, at the time of debate over Phase 2 of the project.]
o Goddard, John, "Sold down the River: The Power and the Politics of Kemano," Harrowsmith, December 1993, No. 112: 38-47.
o Guertin, Gaétan, Claude Demers, Martin Pérusse, "La Grande Rivère: 'In Accord with its Environment', a Case Study," Water Resources Development, 1993, 9(4): 387-409. [Discussion of the James Bay project, from the perspective of Hydro Quebec. Concludes that "[h]ydroelectricity is an energy source compatible with environmental protection and, furthermore, it is renewable."]
o Harrison, Kathryn, Passing the Buck: Federalism and Canadian Environmental Policy, (Vancouver: UBC Press, 1996). [discusses federal-provincial jurisdictional disputes over environmental impact assessment of major Canadian dams.]
o Hood, George N., Against the Flow: Rafferty-Alameda and the Politics of the Environment, (Saskatoon: Fifth House Publishers, 1994)
o Hume, Mark, The Run of the River: Portraits of eleven British Columbia rivers, (Vancouver: New Star Books, 1992).
o Jaccard, Mark, John Nyboer, Timo Makinen, "Managing Instead of Building: B.C. Hydro's Role in the 1990s," BC Studies, 1991-92, no. 91-92: 98+.
o Krotz, Larry, "Dammed and Diverted: Hydro projects in northern Manitoba have irreversibly disrupted the landscape and a way of life. Permafrost was the unknown factor." Canadian Geographic, 1991, 111(1): 36-44.
o McCutcheon, Sean, Electric rivers : the James Bay project, (Montreal: Black Rose Books, 1991).
o Naske, Claus-M., "The Taiya Project [hydrodevelopment in northern BC]," BC Studies, 1991-92, no. 91-92: 5-50.
o Niezen, Ronald, "Power and dignity: The social consequences of hydro-electric development for the James Bay Cree," Canad. Rev. Soc. & Anth., 1993, 30(4): 510-529.
o Pollon, Earl K., Shirlee Smith Matheson, This Was Our Valley, (Calgary: Detselig, 1989). [Comprehensive examination of the history, politics, and impacts (social, economic, environmental) of the Bennett Dam in northern B.C. An interesting parallel perspective to that provided by Christensen (1995).]
o Probe International, "James Bay II". [Collection of newsclippings relating to this project. Useful for study of development of this controversy.]
o Richardson, Boyce. James Bay: the plot to drown the North Woods, (San Francisco: Sierra Club, 1972).
o Richardson, Boyce. Strangers devour the land, (Vancouver: Douglas & McIntyre, 1991).
o Rosenberg, D. M., R. A. Bodaly, P. J. Usher, "Environmental and social impacts of large scale hydro-electric development: who is listening?" Global Environmental Change, 1995, 5(2): 127-148. [Survey of impacts of Canadian hydro projects.]
o Struzik, Ed, "Stopping the River's Flow: Can Wild Rivers Survive our Governments' Love Affair with Dams?" Nature Canada, 1990, 19(1): 30-37. [Survey of Canadian dam-building as a political issue.]
o Tomblin, Stephen G., "W. A. C. Bennett and Province-Building in British Columbia," BC Studies, 1990, no. 85: 45-61.
o Townsend, G. H., "Impact of the Bennett Dam on the Peace-Athabasca Delta," Can. J. Fish. Res. Bd., 1975, 32: 171-176.
o Waldram, James B., As Long as the Rivers Run: Hydroelectric Development and Native Communities in Western Canada, (Winnipeg: U of Manitoba Press, 1988).
o Wilson, J. W., Maureen Conn, "On Uprooting and Rerooting: Reflections on the Columbia River Project," BC Studies, 1983, no. 58: 40-54.
o Wood, Chris, "Powerhouse Politics: Environmentalists wage a bitter battle against a B.C. megaproject," [on Kemano] MacLean's, 1994, May 9, vol. 107(19): 14-16.

 Top of Page     Dams in Canada